Winner: Laura Kaeppeler (Wisconsin)

Miss Alabama Courtney Porter Miss Alaska 2012 Katy Lovegreen Miss Arizona 2011 Jennifer Sedler Miss Arkansas 2011 Kristen Glover
Miss California 2011 Noelle Freeman Miss Colorado 2011 Diana Dreman Miss Connecticut 2011 Morgan Amarone Miss Delaware 2011 Maria Cahill
Miss District of Columbia 2011 Ashley Boalch Miss Florida 2011 Kristina Janolo Miss Georgia 2011 Michaela Grace Lackey Miss Hawaii 2011 Lauren Kealohilani Cheape
Miss Idaho 2011 Genevieve Nutting Miss Illinois 2011 Hannah Smith Miss Indiana 2011 Jackie Jerlecki Miss Iowa 2011 Jessica Pray
Miss Kansas 2011 Carissa Kelley Miss Kentucky 2011 Ann Blair Thornton Miss Louisiana 2011 Hope Anderson Miss Maine 2011 Julia Furtado
Miss Maryland 2011 Carlie Colella Miss Massachusetts 2011 Molly Whalen Miss Michigan 2011 Elizabeth Ann Wertenberger Miss Minnesota 2011 Natalie Davis
Miss Mississippi 2011 Mary Margaret Roark Miss Missouri 2011 Sydney Friar Miss Montana 2011 Veronika Ohlinger Miss Nebraska 2011 Kayla Batt
Miss Nevada 2011 Alana Lee Miss New Hampshire 2011 Regan Elizabeth Hartley Miss New Jersey 2011 Katharyn Nicolle Miss New Mexico 2011 Sarina Turnbull
Miss New York 2011 Kaitlin Monte Miss North Carolina 2011 Hailey Best Miss North Dakota 2011 Ariana Walker Miss Ohio 2011 Ellen Bryan
Miss Oklahoma 2011 Betty Thompson Miss Oregon 2011 Caroline McGowan Miss Pennsylvania 2011 Juliann Sheldon Miss Puerto Rico 2011 Laura Ramirez
Miss Rhode Island 2011 Robin Elizabeth Bonner Miss South Carolina 2011 Bree Boyce Miss South Dakota 2011 Anna Simpson Miss Tennessee 2011 Erin Hatley
Miss Texas 2011 Kendall Morris Miss Utah 2011 Danica Olsen Miss Vermont 2011 Katie Levasseur Miss Virginia 2011 Elizabeth Crot
Miss Virgin Islands 2011 Camila Daniels Miss Washington 2011 Brittney Henry Miss West Virginia 2011 Spenser Wempe Miss Wisconsin 2011 Laura Kaeppeler
Miss Wyoming 2011 Catherine Brown